The buyer quoted to the seller
This is the last contact that I will have on this matter.
> After, almost 27 years of working with the Federal Government in customer
> contact situations and with the U.S. Attorneys Offices in three states I
> have found that those who continue to protest probably are trying to
> obscure something. This may not be true of you but I think that you
> protest too much.
> In the current issue of Antiques and Collecting magazine (August 2005) the
> column "Rinker on Collectibles" by Harry Rinker, puts forth the "Ten
> Common Sense Rules to Determine if an Object is Period, Reproduction, Copy
> Cat, Fantasy or Fake." "Rule Two: If a piece looks new it probably
> is...they should show signs of aging and wear. Aging is the result of
> oxidation (chemicals in the air) and patination (dirt in the air)." Wear
> is from handling and is common on aged pieces that are well loved and
> handled.
> The information that you sent from the Shawnee newsletter offered to
> identify it from a picture which is the same as looking at any of my
> several books. No expert would do that. Then that contact went on the say
> that Ebay users were novices and know little about what they buy which is
> essentially correct, but did not go on to say that about 60% of what is
> identified as Shawnee is not even close. Most are in fact American
> Bisque, Hull and sometimes Royal Copley."
This goes to show what we have to deal with on Ebay - I think all of us as Shawnee collectors can agree to disagree with Rinker in that MANY pieces of Shawnee do in fact appear like new due the quality of the pottery and the way is does sustain it's appearance over some fifty to sixty years.
Here is a cute little Pekingese dog by American pottery company Shawnee. It measures 2 1/2 inches high by 2 3/4 inches long. It is in excellent condition, with no damage or repairs that I can find. There is one glaze flaw on the right ear (see photo) where the purple glaze had a bubble which popped during firing leaving a small spot of missing glaze. This is not a chip - the edges of the bubble area are smooth.
Winning bid: US $20.49 2 bids (US $19.99 starting bid)
Ended: Aug-11-05 18:28:43 PDT Start time: Aug-04-05 18:28:43 PDT